• The World Transformation Movement
  • World Transformation Movement™

    www.HumanCondition.com

Home Publications FREEDOM
loading...

Loading...

Read below, Audio, PDF, Print, eBook, Buy, Translations, Share, Search
Choose option
  • Download or listen to the audio:

    Listen or Download

  • Print your own copy:

    Printing & binding options & instructions

  • Download full PDF:

    A4 PDF US Letter PDF

  • Download eBook:

    Kindle Apple Book Generic

  • Purchase book from Amazon:

    Order from Amazon

  • See translations:

    Dutch French Spanish

  • Share this page:
  • Search FREEDOM: The End Of the Human Condition:
  • Table of Contents
  • Previous section Next section

‘FREEDOM’—Chapter 5  The Origin of Humans’ Moral Instinctive Self or Soul

wtm-pdf-ebook

book

web

Chapter 5:10 The importance of nurturing in bonobo society

  • 5:10
    The importance of nurturing in bonobo society  440–
  • Chapter 5:10  The importance of nurturing in bonobo society

    5:10  The importance of nurturing in bonobo society

    440

    An indication of how bonobos have been able to develop the nurturing love-indoctrination process more than chimpanzees, is that female bonobos have, on average, one offspring every five to six years and provide better maternal care than chimpanzees. Bonobos are born small, develop more slowly than other ape species, and stay in a state of infancy and total dependence for a comparatively long period of time—being weaned at about five years of age and remaining dependent on their mothers until between the ages of seven and nine. Chimpanzees are weaned at about four years of age and remain dependent up to the age of six (on average), while the biological weaning age for humans is considered to be between five-and-a-half and six years, which is closer to the five years of bonobos. Biologists have noted that an individual’s lifespan is, amongst other factors, ‘related to the postnatal development rate’ (Richard Cutler, ‘Evolution of longevity in primates’, Journal of Human Evolution, 1976, Vol.5, No.2), and so it is possible to deduce that the selection for a longer infancy period had the side effect of lengthening all the stages of maturation, which may explain how humans acquired our comparatively long lifespan.

    441

    The primatologist Takayoshi Kano’s long-running study of bonobos in their natural habitat in the Democratic Republic of the Congo has observed this prolonged infancy in practise, reporting that ‘The long dependence of the son may be caused by the slow growth of the bonobo infant, which seems slower than in the chimpanzee. For example, even after one year of age, bonobo infants do not walk or climb much, and are very slow. The mothers keep them near. They start to play with others at about one and a half years, which is much later than in the chimpanzee. During this period, mothers are very attentive…Female juveniles gradually loosen their tie with the mother and travel further away from her than do her sons’ (Frans de Waal & Frans Lanting, Bonobo: The Forgotten Ape, 1997, p.60 of 210). As alluded to in this passage, the bond between mother and son is of particular significance in bonobo society where the son will maintain his connection with his mother for life and depend upon her for his social standing within the group. For example, the son of the society’s dominant female, the strong matriarch who maintains social order, will rise in the ranks of the group, presumably to ensure the establishment and perpetuation of unaggressive, non-competitive, cooperative male characteristics, both learnt and genetic, within the group. Again, historically, it is the male primates who have been particularly divisive in their aggressive competition to win mating opportunities and, therefore, the gender most needing of love-indoctrination—as this quote makes clear: ‘Patient observation over many years convinced [Takayoshi] Kano that male bonobos bonded with their mothers for life. That contrasts with chimpanzee males who rarely have close contact with their mothers after they grow up, instead joining other males in never-ending tussles for dominance’ (Paul Raffaele, ‘Bonobos: The apes who make love, not war’, Last Tribes on Earth.com, 2003; see <www.wtmsources.com/143>).

    442

    The following quote (part of which has already been referred to), from Sue Savage-Rumbaugh and the writer Roger Lewin’s book, Kanzi: The Ape at the Brink of the Human Mind, provides further insight into bonobo society and its emphasis on nurturing: ‘Bonobo life is centered around the offspring. Unlike what happens among common chimps, all members of the bonobo social group help with infant care and share food with infants. If you are a bonobo infant, you can do no wrong. This high regard for infants gives bonobo females a status that is not shared by common chimpanzee females, who must bear the burden of child care all alone. Bonobo females and their infants form the core of the group, with males invited in to the extent that they are cooperative and helpful. High-status males are those that are accepted by the females, and male aggression directed toward females is rare even though males are considerably stronger’ (1994, p.108 of 299).

    443

    Also ‘Unlike what happens among common chimps’ is the fact that bonobos regularly share their food, and while chimpanzees restrict their plant-food intake to mainly fruit, bonobos eat leaves and plant pith as well as fruit, a diet more like that of gorillas. While bonobos have been known to capture and eat small game, including small monkeys, to supplement their diet with protein, they are not known to routinely hunt down and eat large animals such as colobus monkeys, like chimpanzees do, with ‘hunting behavior [by bonobos] very rare’ (Tetsuya Sakamaki quoted by David Quammen, ‘The Left Bank Ape’, National Geographic, Mar. 2013). (In chapter 6:6 it is explained how mechanistic science has had to try to argue that bonobos are not gentle and peaceful because their cooperative behaviour serves as an unbearably exposing and confronting reminder of our now immensely angry, egocentric and alienated, unloving and unloved lives. For example, you will recall how, in par. 208, E.O. Wilson brazenly attempted to paint bonobos as indistinguishable from chimpanzees by stating that, like chimpanzees, bonobos ‘do not share’, and that they ‘hunt in coordinated packs in the same manner as chimpanzees’. However, as I pointed out, even the most basic research shows that Wilson had to fudge his evidence to support his lie—but this is how desperate resigned humans have been to find some excuse for our species’ divisive behaviour.) Also, while physical violence is customary amongst chimpanzees it is rare among bonobos where, although the males are stronger, male aggression has been tamed and, unlike other great apes but like our ancestors, there is actually little difference in sexual size dimorphism between the male and female of the species. And, as has been mentioned, like our ancestors Sahelanthropus, Orrorin and Ardipithecus, bonobos have reduced canine teeth, another indication they are less aggressive—in fact, the bonobo male ‘possesses smaller canines than any other [male] hominoid (J. Michael Plavcan et al., ‘Competition, coalitions and canine size in primates’, Journal of Human Evolution, 1995, Vol.28, No.3). The practice of infanticide, while not uncommon amongst chimpanzees, also appears to be non-existent within bonobo societies where even orphan bonobos are cared for by the group. In chimpanzee society orphans are occasionally adopted by a female but are not especially cared for by the group. Social groups of bonobos also have much greater stability than social groups of chimpanzees, with bonobos periodically coming together in large, harmonious, stable groups of up to 120 individuals—as Barbara Fruth’s observation, included in par. 415, indicated: ‘up to 100 bonobos at a time from several groups spend their night together. That would not be possible with chimpanzees because there would be brutal fighting between rival groups.’ The primatologist Genichi Idani similarly reported that ‘In societies of African great apes other than bonobos, only antagonistic [aggressive] relationships have been reported between unit-groups…[Bonobo] neighborhood relationships…allow peaceful coexistence of two unit-groups [and] provide the first nonhuman primate community model which is close to…​human society’ (‘Relations between Unit-Groups of Bonobos at Wamba, Zaire: Encounters and Temporary Fusions’, African Study Monographs, 1990, Vol.11, No.3). So, bonobos are much gentler than their chimpanzee cousins; they are relatively placid, peaceful and egalitarian, exhibiting a remarkable sensitivity to others—and not just towards their own kind, as will be evidenced shortly with an account of how a bonobo cared for a stunned bird.

    Back
    Kindle eBook options
    • Please Note: for the best reading experience on Kindle devices and apps we recommend downloading the file directly from Amazon (the file is provided in the latest KF8 format and will work correctly on all devices).
    • From Amazon (KF8 format)
    • Alternatively, you can download the file from here using the older MOBI format. For all devices except Kindle Fire you will need to download the file to your computer first and then transfer it to you device (with Kindle Fire, you can download it directly.)
    • Standard Kindle (MOBI format)
    • (NOTE: The MOBI format will not display correctly on iPhones and iPads. If you wish to download the ebook to an iPad or iPhone we recommend either downloading the file directly from Amazon or using the Apple Books version instead.)
    • eBook Help and Troubleshooting
    Back
    Apple Book Options
    • Select either:
    • Download the Apple Book from here
    • OR
    • Download from the Apple Books store
    • but this does involve more steps
    • (there is no cost involved in either option)
    • eBook Help and Troubleshooting
    Back

    Generic eBook Options

    • This file is for all devices and apps other than Kindle and iBooks, such as for Androids.
    • Select either:
    • Download the epub file from here
    • OR
    • From Google Play
    • Alternatively, if you using a Kobo device then please download directly from the Rakuten Kobo store to ensure the ebook displays with correct fonts and formatting:
    • From Rakuten Kobo

    For more info see eBook Help and Troubleshooting

    Back
    Print Options
    • You have 2 options:
    • 1.  To print all, or some, of ‘FREEDOM’ in specially laid out PDF, click here.
    • 2.  To print just the section you are in of ‘FREEDOM’ in specially laid out PDF, choose either: US Letter PDF or A4 PDF.
    • For more info see PDF Help and Troubleshooting
    • Table of Contents
    • Previous section Next section

    This is a scientific pursuit and was not created for profit. For this reason, all information and materials are provided free of charge.

    Share this page
    Print this page

    Copyright © Fedmex Pty Ltd (ACN 096 099 286) 1998-2023 | All rights reserved | View our Terms of use, Privacy policy, or cookie policy | Media Enquiries

    Contact
    x
    Contact Us
      • Website: www.HumanCondition.com
      • Email: [email protected]
      • Phone: + 61 (0)2 9279 4060

      The WTM is represented by two registered charities, one in Sydney, Australia, and another in New York, USA, and by WTM Centres around the world – see WTM Organisations page and WTM Centres page.

      For general enquiries or feedback:

    • By clicking ‘send’ you confirm that you have read, understood and accept the WTM’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. The WTM will only contact you in relation to this enquiry and will manage all personal information in accordance with its Privacy Policy.

    • Hidden

    Please note, because we are a charity with limited resources, we may not respond to questions or criticisms already prominently answered on our comprehensive website with its many freely available books, essays and FAQs that can be easily searched electronically.

    • Subscribe To The
      WTM Mailing List

      and receive notifications of live events, one free essay by Jeremy Griffith each week, and rare news flashes. I understand I can opt out any time (Privacy Policy).

    • Hidden
    • Hidden
    • Hidden
    • Hidden
    • Hidden
    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

    x World Transformation Movement Logo
    • HOME
    • CONTACT
    • SEARCH
    • Resolution of the human condition

    • Books by Jeremy Griffith
    • Translations
    • Videos
    • Essays
    • Live Events
    • FAQs
    • Commendations
    • Publicity
    • About the WTM

    • The WTM
    • The Great Transformation
    • Jeremy Griffith
    • How To Help
    • Media Facility
    • WTM Centres
    • Community
    • Members
    • Join Mailing List
    • Join Facebook Group
    • Other Social Media
    • Helpful tools

    • Contact Us
    • WTM App
    • Share
    • Search
    • Print
    • Donate
    • Products
      • Share this page

      • Print this page

        A4 PDF US Letter PDF
    • Visit the WTM Social Media

    This website uses cookies

    We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our website, to show you personalized content and targeted ads, to analyze our website traffic, and to understand where our visitors are coming from. You can change your preferences at any time by visiting our Cookie policy page.

    Accept cookies Cookie options

    HumanCondition.com Search Results

      Filter results by specific document type:

      Entire Website
      • Entire Website
      • Books by Jeremy Griffith
      • Freedom Essays
      • FAQs
      • Video & Audio Transcripts
      • Blog
      • PDFs
      • Images

      Filter search results for specific books

      • FREEDOM
      • Transform Your Life
      • Death by Dogma
      • Freedom Expanded 1
      • Freedom Expanded 2
      • Book of Answers
      • Human Condition Doco Proposal
      • The Great Exodus
      • A Species In Denial
      • Beyond
      • Free

      Showing results (includes EXACT & CLOSE matches) for ‘’ from Entire Website:

      Sorry, we couldn’t find any results matching ‘’.

      You haven’t searched anything yet. Please use the search field above to start a search.